Skip to content

Cardinal Pizzaballa: Two-state solution unrealistic for Israel-Hamas

Card. Pierbattista Pizzaballa - presa di possesso del Titolo di Sant'Onofrio. Credit: Vatican Media

Latin Patriarch of Jerusalem Cardinal Pierbattista Pizzaballa said that, at the moment, a two-state solution to end the war between Israel and Hamas in the Holy Land “is not realistic.”

“My impression is that no one wants a wider conflict, but no one is able to stop it,” Pizzaballa said in an exclusive interview with EWTN’s Colm Flynn. “Now there is a need for something new, creative, I don’t know what, but all the previous agreements, the ideas, the prospect of a two-state solution, all that is not realistic now,” the cardinal explained. Pizzaballa described the war between Israel and Hamas, which began Oct. 7, 2023, as the worst period the people of the Holy Land have experienced in 35 years.

“Not only because of the violence … but because of the scope, the impact, even the emotional impact on the population, both Israeli and Palestinian, and now in Lebanon, which is enormous,” he added.

After the Hamas incursion into Israel on Oct. 7, 2023, Israel responded with a major military operation in Gaza, which also involved Iran and Lebanon. In recent months, Pope Francis has repeatedly called for a ceasefire and an end to the war in the Holy Land, especially after the Angelus prayer on Sunday. On Oct. 17, he received a former Israeli prime minister and three former high-ranking Palestinian ministers at the Vatican to discuss the situation.

In the interview, Pizzaballa expressed concern about the “language of hatred” present everywhere. “This is terrible. And my concern is not so much about the war. Wars are not eternal; they end, like all wars, but what comes next, the consequences, will be terrible.”

The Church is the voice of the poor

Regarding the negotiations necessary to achieve peace, the cardinal commented, “I don’t think the Church should get into these things. The Church is better off staying out … because if you get in, you are no longer free. The strength of the Church is to be a voice, the voice of the poor.”

After stressing that “everyone has to do their job, politicians have to find a political perspective and religious leaders have to help people find hope.” The Jerusalem Patriarch also clarified that “peace is an attitude. It is not just an agreement.”

However, Pizzaballa continued, given the current context “it is unrealistic to talk about peace. Now, what we need to talk about first is a cease-fire, to stop all forms of violence…and also find a new leadership with vision, a political vision, and also religious leaders. Only then can we think about a new perspective for the Middle East, but not before.”

On the use of hunger as a weapon of war

The cardinal expressed regret over what is happening in Gaza and stressed that aid sent by international organizations is not enough to assist the 2 million people there.

Asked what Christians outside the Holy Land can do, Pizzaballa said, “Pray and support. Support the Christian community as much as possible.”

Message to Israelis and Palestinians

After reiterating that violence is not a solution, the Jerusalem Patriarch insisted that “Palestinians and Israelis are called by God to live side by side, not against each other. And they must rediscover this call.”
He also stressed that “the answer to violence and evil is the cross.” He said that “it is not impossible to see God in the midst of all this because “the Gospel is not an idea or a narrative, it is life,” and stressed the need to “trust more in the power of God’s grace.”

Receive the most important news from EWTN Vatican via WhatsApp. It has become increasingly difficult to see Catholic news on social media. Subscribe to our free channel today

Share

Would you like to receive the latest updates on the Pope and the Vatican

Receive articles and updates from our EWTN Newsletter.

More news related to this article

Honoring persecuted Middle East Christians, Pope Francis adds Assyrian saint to Martyrology

Pope Francis announced on Saturday that St. Isaac of Nineveh, a seventh-century Assyrian bishop venerated across Christian traditions, will be added to the Roman Martyrology.

Pope Francis Wraps Up Historic Mongolia Visit, Addresses Geopolitical Significance

Pope Francis returns from historic Mongolia visit with messages of peace, charity, and insights on Vatican-China relations.

How Benedict XVI lived the first days after his resignation

Archbishop Georg Gänswein, who was Benedict XVI’s personal secretary, describes in his memoirs the days following the resignation

Cardinal O’Malley: Church acknowledges damage of abuse but ‘celibacy is not the cause’

Cardinal Seán O’Malley stressed that “celibacy is not the cause of pedophilia” but highlighted the need for more reforms within the Church.

Restoring the Vatican Museums 

The 40th Anniversary of the Patrons of the Arts of the Vatican Museums

The dubia were not meant as an attack on the pope, Cardinal Burke says

Cardinal Raymond Burke has spoken out on the reactions raised by the “dubia” he and four other cardinals submitted to

LIVE
FROM THE VATICAN

Be present live on EWTNit